The Property Brothers Reveal One Thing Never, Ever To Do to an Old House

Renovating an older home can be rewarding—full of character, charm, and history. But according to Drew and Jonathan Scott, better known as The Property Brothers, there’s one mistake homeowners should never, ever make when upgrading an old property:

Don’t strip away its original character.

What They Mean:

While modern updates are important for safety and comfort, the Property Brothers warn against over-modernizing an old home to the point where it loses its soul. Too often, homeowners:

• Rip out original hardwood floors

• Remove vintage molding and trim

• Replace antique windows with generic ones

• Cover up classic brick or stone with plain drywall

Why It’s a Big Mistake:

1. You Lose Value:
   Original features can actually increase a home’s value. Buyers often pay more for authenticity and charm.

2. It Hurts Resale Appeal:
   Older homes with preserved character stand out in a sea of generic remodels.

3. It Destroys Craftsmanship:
   Many features in older homes were handcrafted—the kind of details modern builders can’t replicate affordably.

What to Do Instead:

• Restore rather than replace original woodwork

• Modernize kitchens and bathrooms carefully, blending old and new

• Preserve historical elements while upgrading systems (electrical, HVAC, plumbing)

Final Word from the Property Brothers:

“It’s okay to modernize, but don’t erase the story your home was built to tell.”